Sunday, 24 November 2013

"The Yellow People”?

Why it is that media is so biased against the Eastern Asians? Why does it show them in a specific negative light? Is it really fair to the Asians, when they are misrepresented in the media? The media today, is one heck of a stereotypical, racist and politicized medium. How would you feel if people of your race, colour or ethnicity were being misrepresented on a consistent basis? It is our media which is highly racist and unfair to the people of  East Asian background. Asians are always shown inferior and unimportant in many media TV shows, commercials ,advertisement, etc.Asians are people with just a different culture who share the same planet as who live, eat, breathe, act and feelings and emotions just like us. They are one of us and aren't different from us in any aspect of life. 

With the media portrayal, they are shown as a nerds, spies, gangsters, and people who are excessively close to their culture has only recently emerged; prior to this Asian men and women were shown as spies from Japan. This relates back to the Pearl Harbour incident. Now, since Japan and United States are on good diplomatic terms this hatred has shifted to China; in TV shows today most Chinese people are shown as spies. Overall, one way or the other the media finds a way to crucify the culture of Eastern Asians, rather than celebrate it. This shows that media is politicized; it is not independent in its opinion. 

Moreover, the media has defined a specific role of Asians in our society and our culture. They are known as people who have connections with triads (gangs), they are depicted as nerds, spies and people who have strong ties to their culture. Many times, it has been the case that Asians are not considered a part of the majority. In America and Canada they are several examples that this is the case. For example, in the TV show CSI: Crime Scene Investigation the forensic doctor of the investigating team is shown as a nerdy and an unattractive person. In the show narrow Asian people are shown as gangsters and part of triads. In NCIS: Los Angeles many episodes show Asian people as Chinese spies. In the Canadian TV show Murdoch Mysteries in an episode Asian people are always shown wearing their cultural clothing. Similarly, in an ad featuring Lebron James, shows him winning from the Chinese god in a one-on-one game. This ad goes way beyond just simple stereotype of cultural clothing and martial arts moves. In my view it shows China against the Americans and shows the victory of Americans over Chinese people. It again demeans them Asian culture.

 Not only that, but the dominant discourse of today’s society proclaimed Asian people who lack communications skills, are shy, overachievers and technologically savvy. There are several of examples of such cases. For example, in Law & Order: SVU, forensic psychiatrist George Huang is shown as a nerdy, and an intelligent man who has extraordinary thinking skills. Moreover, another character from the TV series “Lost”, Jim Kwon is a character who does not speak English at all is shown as a son of poor fisherman from a Korean background. It does not end there, the media find more ways of stereotyping against East Asians such as showing Isabella from “Miami Vice” and Hiro Nakamura from the TV show “Heroes” as untrustworthy, evil, foreign people who could not fully absorb in the American culture. 

Apart from all that, the young famous NBA Asian basketball player Jeremy Lin who currently plays for Houston Rockets was called for a Taiwanese Talk show, and have been reported saying, “I have been racially discriminated when I was in college…There are a lot of slurs being shouted by the crowd” while the games is on. This type of misrepresentation affects the American and Canadian youth who are studying with their Asian peers and problematic situations will appear such as hate crime, racial discrimination, racial harassment and bullying. Now the question arises, why do we let media define our lives?



(In this ad, everyone despite being black or white all the actors are shown 
to have been wearing typical western clothing and speaking English with a
proper accent. In comparison with that, we see two Eastern Asian men dressed
in Martial Art uniform and speak in their weak English accent. Also their dancing style
is the media's art of mocking people's culture. This video hints a little stereotype the 
American media presents in to make fun of someone's background)

Questions to reflect upon:


Have you ever been through racial discrimination at school?


Would there be a time, when we will stop discriminating among your peers and not let media 
shape our perceptions about Asians?


Do you think that these stereotypes hold any truth in them?


If you were to work in the media industry, what would you do to tackle this issue?

13 comments:

  1. Mr. Alvi great post. I will start off by answering your second question. I think there will be a time when discriminating among our peers and our stereotypical views on Asians will change. Likewise, I will have to say that media is bombarding us really hard and to change our perceptions on Asians will not change easily. We are constantly influenced with all types of media including the stereotypical Asian. The dominant discourse has gone past the line and I believe that trying to turn around will be near impossible. If we all were to collectively stop consuming media that proclaims the stereotypical Asians, then the time of discrimination will end. You never know until it happens.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, Mr Dina, you are correct. But what we CAN do is be good to our peers and not be discriminating against our own mates. We need to have tolerance and need to be patient and nice to people with different backgrounds and cultures. We need to put our racial jokes apart and look at the bigger picture, we need to realize that everyone has different experiences throughout their life, so what ever we say to people should be carefully thought before saying. At last, we all have different backgrounds and need to develop a respective multicultural society.

      Delete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for bringing this up Bilal, i completely agree that media misrepresents all east asians. I would like to start off by answering yes to the first question. In my middle school years, the same supply teacher often picked on me to answer math questions, of course there were other students that were capable but he chose me, expecting me to provide the correct answer. At times when i don't know the answer, he would scold me and make false remarks that my "kind" study the lesson everyday and that they should know it. Another experience, would be in my phys ed class, my peers would never pass the ball to me nor to my other Asian friends in a game of soccer or basketball, making false claims that i was terrible at them,it implied that Asians incapable of playing sports. I agree with Endrit that the amount of representation of Asians media has shown to us is going to be difficult to change. I would suggest an attempt to convince the world that not all Asians have the same traits and attributes by sending messages opposing against medias portrayal of east Asians.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Philip I have to agree with you that we need to convince the world that stereotyping Asians is truly disrespectful and horrible. We have to collectively come together and tell the world that what they see in the media is wrong.

      Delete
    2. Philip, Thanks for bringing up you personal experiences that you had when you faced such discrimination in your academic life. I would start by saying Asians, specifically are people who get targeted the most by racial discrimination. One reason for that is that people think all Asian people are smart, and ask questions to their Asian peers about math, english or anything, and when they don't get an answer for that question, they surprisingly start pointing out faults and expect perfection from those Asian individuals. Another reason for racial discrimination is the perception of random public about certain Asian individuals. They think they are smart, and can beat them in studies, so they are jealous, and insecure. This type of misrepresentation creates hatred and resentment even among the minority. It is surprising to see how some individuals who are also Asians make racist jokes about their own race and support racism in a "joke way".

      Delete
  4. Bilal I personally agree with you on how East Asians are being portrayed in media. Just like you have mentioned, this has become a dominant discourse in our society. It is true that many East Asians are seen as nerds, spies, gangsters in movies and TV series. Even though this is stereotyping, people consider all the stuff they see on TV to be true. That is why we see many people today calling Asians such words as "smart, immigrant, spy etc..". In other words the media has brainwashed us into thinking about Asians in a negative way which is very inappropriate. To answer question number 2, I believe that there will be time when people will think again about what the media is conveying to them rather than believing everything that is stated on TV and movies. In addition, we must think logically and not let media manipulate us into believing certain things. In these cases we must not let media change our views on how we see East Asians in our society.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'd like to say I noticed a couple of really nice metaphors and use of media terms. Yes i have been discriminated against, but at the same time I believe everyone has been discriminated against. Blacks for being ghetto, Asians for their mathematical skills or even white people for being extremely privileged and being oppressors. As long as we allow a small amount of people to control what is being output on media. The owners of media are constructing their own ideas, beliefs and values, there needs to be larger amount of input from a variety of people to get a unbiased message across. Sadly, the chances of that happening are not much because of the time and resources it would take. Some stereotypes hold a bit of truth in them. In China there is a wide variety of food, that is strange to people in the western world. We take that unfamiliarity and exaggerate it to a large degree and that some how in turn makes us feel better about ourselves. We don't really need to be in media to tackle this issue. If a large amount of people make enough of a complaint for stereotypes to be removed from media, and make a commitment not to support companies with stereotypical advertisements there would be a large decline in stereotypes overall. In reality, the probability of that occurring is very low because most people are too comfortable with their lives, fear criticism, hard work and would rather not put in the effort to receive equality.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Great post Bilal. As an individual I feel that there will always be stereotypes in the media of practically every group of people. Whether Asians, Blacks, White, Middle Eastern, Latinos etc. At the end of the day it's how we consumers (audience) decide to accept it and allow for it to happen. So to answer question three, I do not think that these stereotypes hold any truth in them. You cannot stereotype a whole nation just because you've seen several people good at something or a group of people do some sort of incident. Everyone is their own self and stereotypes shouldn't define what a certain nation is capable and incapable of doing.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Bilal, I like that your post brought up some negative stereotypes of Eastern Asian. I never thought about Eastern Asians being depicted as gangsters or having their culture made fun of. The only stereotypes I had in mind were the ones of them being intelligent, and pretty much what you stated in paragraph 4. So, I guess the stereotypes given to Eastern Asians does go unnoticed because many people only consciously notice the stereotypes I had, which in this society are considered being positive ( like being a nerd), but unconsciously notice the negative ones that still changed their perception of how Asians are (like them having strong ties to only Eastern Asian cultures and only liking their kind). I sure don't believe these stereotypes have any truth to them.

    -Lydia

    ReplyDelete
  8. Being asian myself, I have faced some of these stereotypes like I'm good at math or science, but it's not really a bad stereotype at all. Are we being made fun of for being intelligent? In my opinion, I don't think there will ever be a time where people will stop being discriminated against. There will always be negative people out there, but so far there has been an improvement against racism with not only Asians but with every race. These stereotypes do hold some truth in them. Being raised by old fashioned Asian parents made me realize that they mostly want their kids to excel in either math or science. Of course, you cannot simply stereotype a whole race based on what a handful of people are doing and not doing. Great post, Bilal!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Good post Bilal. To answer question one, i would have to say, yes, i have been racially discriminated against. However, i was able to deal with it in an appropriate manner and it never happened in the same way again. No matter what, i think that almost everyone will be discriminated against at some point in time. My answer to question two would be that i think most stereotypes have some historical reference in them, meaning that it is possible that they may have some truth in them.

    ReplyDelete
  10. As I walked around the school on the first day, peoples started to call me CHING CHOng girl , or Chinese girl without asking whether I’m Chinese or not. We are on the way, but in order to completely stop discriminating, we should against the way how media portray Asian. Because if the media is continue to misrepresented Asian, then the next generations will continue to think that way.

    ReplyDelete

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.