Thursday, 28 November 2013

Watch Out Ese, It's The Border Patrol

OH THE IRONY!
Do you  find this to be comedic or offensive?
Offensive isn't it! For any of you who don't know, "ese" is a Spanish word that literally translates to "that" ("that" key or "that" boat). However, over time this word has come to have another meaning which is equivalent to "dude" or "homie". If it is not obvious by now, ese, used in this sense, is a slang term used by the stereotypical Mexican/Cuban seen is various movies. ["Que pasa ese?" is a common phrase used by what the average Joe calls "chollo" (gangster)] Before i continue on, i should state that the politically correct term that is used to reference Mexicans and Cubans, ect, is Latino. However, many individuals say that the politically correct term is actually Hispanic. This is because it was coined by the US Census Bureau in the 70s and it groups together all Spanish speaking people regardless of race/nationality. However, for this post i will be using the term Latino because i find it to be more PC. (I am truly sorry if this offends anyone.)


Have you ever noticed what the dominant discourse says about the average Latino? It says that they all come from South America, they are are illegals, they steal jobs, they all speak Spanish, all the females work as maids, they all eat tacos/burritos, they are all gangsters and they all have long names (usually the typical ones: Jose, Rodriguez, Jorge ect). Sadly, those were just a few of the many currently circulating throughout society. I would now like you to take a couple of minutes and watch the video presented above. Before you watch, you must know that there is profanity involved in it. You have been warned. The video that i have shown above is not to be deconstructed because there is no need for that. It is not like the video in my previous post where i took it apart and while one could do the same to this, it is not necessary. However, i would like to point out a couple of things. While this video was dramatic for comedic purposes, i do agree with many of the points that it made. It's also interesting to see that the video points out that housekeepers are looked down upon, are blamed for actions they did not commit and are treated very disrespectfully. Before i finish talking about this video, i would like to point out one more thing that i found to be quite intriguing. Did you notice that to exemplify the Latino stereotypes, the video uses Caucasian (PC) stereotypes? The Caucasian woman in the video embodies many Caucasian stereotypes. Some of these stereotypes seen in the video are: Caucasians are condescending, they are close minded, they are stupid and they are rich and conceited. Irony, why art thou so beautiful?


Most of these common stereotypes that media presents to us are shown largely on television. It is sad to see so many programs that have characters that portray the stereotypical Latino. Let's take into consideration the show, Devious Maids. I have presented to you the trailer for the show just to give you a glimpse of what the show is about. There are a few problems that i have with this series and i would like to address them. The first issue that i have is fairly obvious: the lead characters are all maids...who are all Latino. Now, don't get me wrong, there is nothing wrong with working as a maid (the world revolves around money). However, i do have a problem with the American entertainment industry because it constantly tells Latinas that this is all they can ever achieve. Continuing on, i find it to be offensive that in the show the maids are seen to be people who love to gossip, act sassy around their employers and regularly dine is fancy cafes. This does not make sense and not only is it stereotypical but it is also inappropriate to portray Latinos in this way. On another note, although this does not tie in with Latino stereotypes, i should mention that this show also exhibits Caucasian and general maid stereotypes. All the employers in the show are Caucasian and they all are snobby, pompous and loathsome. (Caucasian Stereotypes) Also, the show provides viewers with some maid stereotypes which say that they are all unfaithful, charming, sneaky and that they all wear the same coloured uniforms (black and white).

Let's move away from Devious Maids and go onto a show that most of us know. A show that is comedic, racist, offensive and animated. The name of this nefarious show is Family Guy.  One of the show's characters is Consuela, a Latino maid. She speaks in broken English, cleans all the time and is hardly ever seen in anything other than a housekeeper's outfit. Now, i understand that Family Guy is a humorous show that is meant to be offensive and is meant to take aim at social groups, but the only reason i mention it is for you to get some information on how the dominant discourse portrays Latino stereotypes in television programs. Finally, let's take a look at the show Heroes. The only two Latino characters, Alejandro and Maya Herrera, in the show are shown to be siblings who have crossed the border into America illegally.  While they are shown to be major characters, the brother is killed off early on and as the show goes on their story line becomes erratic and inconsistent. Compare this to the other major characters (even some of the minor characters) and you will see how small of a part they play in the show. It is sad to see that when they are important during scenes, the lines are so cheesy and stereotypical that it makes viewers slightly dislike the writers of the show.

I would like to leave you all with these questions. Ponder upon them, derive an answer and spark a discussion below. Thank you all for reading. Please forgive any grammatical errors and if i need to correct/clarify anything, please tell me (comment).

1. Do you think tv shows like Family Guy and South Park have negative effects on their viewers? If so, then what are they?
2. Have you seen "Devious Maids"? If you have, what do you think of it? If not, then would you like to watch it?
3. In what other shows have you seen Latino stereotypes?
4. Latino or Hispanic, which do you think is more appropriate?
5. Why do you think writers and producers constantly build Latino characters around stereotypes?
6. Other than on television, where else have you seen stereotypes (more specifically Latino stereotypes) being used?
7. Do you think that sometimes writes put in a coloured character not to improve the story line itself, but to prove that the show is culturally diverse? (Wouldn't this get them higher views?)

15 comments:

  1. Great Article Fawad. To address the first question, i would say that Family Guy and South Park are undoubtedly the most racist TV shows in the media. They are stereotypical and racist, with their scripts, graphics and sounds, and i don't think anyone might disagree with me on that point. Despite these things we still continue enjoy watching TV shows like these and end up getting influenced by it's negative perspectives. These two TV shows insinuate hatred among a community or ethnicity. For example, Muslims, and Latinos. Now, to jump on the fifth question i would say the reason why writers and producers constantly build Latino characters around stereotypes is because of the actual organized crimes and corruption that takes place in South America. Surely that does not mean that ever person who is belongs to a Latin or Spanish descent is a criminal but that is what we hear in the news, and that is what ends up being shown in TV shows, Movies and music videos. Personally, i am against these type of stereotypes and racist acts, but if we honestly think about it, every ethnicity, religion and race have stereotypes and that is the truth about today's patronization in the human race.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Bilal. You had some very interesting points and i would like to address some of them. You said, "Despite these things we still continue enjoy watching TV shows like these and end up getting influenced by it's negative perspectives." Does this mean that you are negatively influenced by these shows? If not, then what is stopping you from getting influenced by them? Also i really like the points you made in regards to question 5.

      Delete
    2. Also i did a little research and found a site rated Family guy as the 5th most racist show. Number 1 was...Fox News.
      http://www.complexmag.ca/pop-culture/2013/05/most-racist-tv-shows/fox-news

      Delete
  2. I really liked your article Fawad, being a "Hispanic" or "Latino" person myself it was interesting to read all that. To answer your fourth question, as a person from that community I really don't care whether someone calls me "Hispanic" or "Latino" because it generally means the same thing and it's not as bad as referring a spanish speaking person as Mexican. The first video I found pretty offensive but funny at the same time. I actually have family who work as "maids" but their employers are not as ridiculous as the women in that video. They actually respect them and treat them equally which is the way everyone should be treated. To answer questions two, I haven't watched "Devious Maids" but I would only to see how inaccurate they portray Hispanic women who are maids. It's sad to see all these stereotypes in the media but you can't really run from them, it's everyone and it targets everyone.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Monica. It's good to hear that the employers are not like the stereotypical ones shown "Devious Maids". As i mentioned in the article, i think that the Caucasian stereotypes are over the top because they want to elevate the Latino stereotypes.From what i have seen of the show, i declare that it is a waste of time. There are many plot holes and overall it is fairly offensive. You said, " you can't really run from them, it's everyone and it targets everyone." I strongly agree with this. However, i must pose this question to you. With that statement being true, how can one reduce the negative affects that stereotypes have on them?

      Delete
    2. To answer your question Fawad, I think the media has a lot to do with these stereotypes and if they were to ease up on them (however humorous they are) then maybe people would understand that it isn't right. Also we could stop generalizing people and understand that just because some Hispanics are maids it doesn't mean that all Hispanics are maids or just because some Asian people (by this I do refer to Japanese, Chinese, etc) are good at math, doesn't mean they all are. This is the way I see it, I do want to know how you would answer that question.

      Delete
    3. Very good point Monica. I agree that media has a lot to do with spreading stereotypes but sadly this is something that cannot be stopped. There will always be people who will not be able to critically analyse media and understand the true meaning behind it. The way i would answer is that we must be the change that we want in the world. I have to look a the "man in the mirror" and understand that change begins with a few. Eventually non-stereotypical ideologies will spread and one can hope hope that the dominant discourse will change along with mindsets. (however, there will always be people who will have stereotypical/racist views)

      Delete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. What a great post Fawad, I'll start off by answering your first question. Family guy and south park are just cartoons for entertainment, however they can take things to a certain point. For example, there are many racist jokes that are being mention on family guy which entertain the audience, also it does give them a negative effect. For instance, if a teen hears one of the jokes from family guy and mentions it to a group of Hispanic people, it is obvious that the Hispanic individuals would find that offensive. To answer question # 7, I believe that adding colored characters to cartoon, it is actually stereotyping them in a way. For example, if a Hispanic person is featured on family guy committing a crime, people would find it funny however the Hispanic people wouldn't. In other words, stereotyping people from other races boost's the number of views which increases profit for these companies. as a result, stereotyping minorities and people on TV are just money making schemes.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hmmmmmmmm i see what you are saying. Should tv shows like the aforementioned be allowed to present such material? Here is another question that comes to mind, do you think that the viewers are being to sensitive? What i mean by this is that since we know that the shows are meant to be offensive, are people taking the shows too seriously?

      Delete
    2. By the way, thanks for the positive response man.

      Delete
    3. Personally, I do not think that people take shows seriously, unless it actually offends a certain group of people. We see that in the western society, people enjoy watching TV and movies, and therefore when it comes to a racist scene people would find that funny since it is a form of entertainment for them. For example, if we look at comedy, Russel Peters makes a lot of racial jokes which are only for entertainment purposes however some people may find it offensive. In addition, I would like to say that the western society does not really take things TV seriously since they just believe its for entertainment.

      Delete
    4. Very good point Kulvir. I would have to agree that people in this part of the world are more lenient towards such forms of entertainment.

      Delete
  5. Great post, I will also give my answer to the first question. I don't really have any worries that shows like south park and family guy would affect the average person negatively, most people watch those shows with an open mind and are looking for comedy. So they would take most of what they hear with a grain of salt. In contrary to that I do think that those shows perpetuate stereotypes pretty well, which could be a problem depending on the person who views it, but as long as it is watched with an open mind, it shouldn't cause a ruckus.

    ReplyDelete

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.